BRIDGEPORT, CT — On Tuesday, Nov. 17, police took a 31-year-old man into custody and charged him with murdering 24-year-old Evelyn Rayo-Mairena, who was killed on Black Rock Avenue on Oct. 21, 2025. The address is on Bridgeport's West Side. Police said the man was brought to the Bridgeport Police Department from the Montgomery County Jail outside Houston, Texas.
In late January 2026, police announced an arrest warrant for the 30-year-old suspect and said the department was working with the State Department on his return. Police said someone drove him to New York's JFK International Airport, and he then traveled through El Salvador to Nicaragua.
Bridgeport Police Detective Jeffrey Holtz called the outcome rare. "This is an extremely rare and remarkable outcome," he said in a press release, crediting the department's homicide and major crimes detectives and its Fugitive Unit, along with Interpol, the U.S. Marshals Service and the State and Justice departments.
How Police Say the Killing Unfolded
Rayo-Mairena was found in the street around 9:30 p.m., shot in the head, and later died at St. Vincent's Hospital, police said. Her 1-year-old daughter was found on a nearby porch, unhurt, in a car seat beside a bloodied baby blanket.
Investigators believe the suspect shot Rayo-Mairena inside his car, placed the baby on the porch and pulled Rayo-Mairena into the street. Police have not named the person who drove him to the airport. Investigators are trying to determine whether the driver knew of the killing and whether additional charges could follow.
NBC Connecticut reported that the suspect is held on a $4 million bond and faces charges of tampering with physical evidence, murder, and risk of injury to a minor. Police said the suspect and Rayo-Mairena both emigrated from Nicaragua and were friends from the same hometown.
Investigators Describe a Working Theory
Holtz said investigators believe the suspect wanted a relationship with Rayo-Mairena and that she turned him down. "If I can't have her, nobody will have her," Holtz said, describing the working theory.
Rayo-Mairena's sister, Carolina, said the arrest showed the family had received justice. "This proves that justice was accomplished," she said. Police Chief Roderick Porter said the department is confident the family will receive the justice they deserve, Patch reported.
The Nicaraguan government offered to prosecute him there, but the offer was declined, FOX61 reported. The United States and Nicaragua have no extradition treaty, Holtz said.